12 Sweet Spots for Dessert in Port St. Lucie

No visit to the Treasure Coast would be complete without taking in plenty of the local eats, and of course, no local culinary adventure is complete without a sweet finish at one of the many spots for dessert in Port St. Lucie.

But where do you go when you want to get a sweet treat and don’t feel like going to the usual Dairy Queen or similar type of place?

After all, you’re in Port St. Lucie, one of the Treasure Coast’s most picturesque towns with some of the best hidden gems for dessert.

We’ve compiled this extensive list of all of the best spots for dessert in Port St. Lucie, so that when your sweet tooth strikes, you’ll have the ideal lineup of ideal places to get your fix.

Here are the best sweet spots for Dessert in Port St. Lucie.

Joy’s Ice Cream Plus

joys ice cream port st lucie fl

For some of the best homemade ice cream on the Treasure Coast, you’ll have to stop by Joy’s Ice Cream Plus.

Often praised by locals for their top-tier customer service and very generous portions, this cozy ice cream shop is great for a family outing or just a casual ice cream treat.

The quality and variety of the ice cream flavors here is one of the biggest draws, with several unique flavors that are just begging to be put in a cone and enjoyed.

That Crepe Place

That Crepe Place offers visitors the perfect way to experience a little savory with their sweet, with its expansive offering of crepes that appeal to a wide variety of tastes.

This is a cozy little place that crafts fresh, made-to-order crepes, and fills each one with a combination of palate-pleasing ingredients and flavor blends.

The sweet crepes are the most popular, and feature options like Nutella and fresh fruit options, while the warm and inviting ambiance makes the ideal space to relax and savor them.

Bomboloni Bakery-Café

cafe dessert port st lucie

The Bomboloni Bakery-Café near Port St. Lucie offers a luxurious taste of Italy, with its selection of authentic Italian pastries served in a warm and inviting atmosphere.

As the name suggests, the bakery specializes in bomboloni, which are Italian filled doughnuts, but their expertise doesn’t stop there, they also create countless other Italian confections.

The Bomboloni Bakery-Café is the perfect spot for authentic Italian baked goods, but their hours do vary so it’s best to double-check before you plan a trip to the cafe.

St Lucie Bakery

st lucie bakery desserts

St Lucie Bakery is a beloved family-owned establishment and is renowned for its authentic Italian pastries, breads, and baked goods.

They’ve been serving the Port St. Lucie area for more than 20 years, and offer some of the most delectable items, including vanilla bean cheesecakes, chocolate chip pistachio rolls, caramel tarts, croissant, cannoli, rugelach, and much more.

It’s pretty challenging to find an Italian bakery more authentic than St Lucie Bakery, and it usually involves traveling a lot farther than Port St. Lucie.

Costa Cafe & Bakery

Costa Cafe & Bakery is a charming little spot that is well-known for its whimsical selection of baked goods and its cozy cafe atmosphere, and it stands out for its array of treats that are always fresh-baked.

Available delights include pastries, cakes, and breads, with nearly everything becoming a favorite for those looking for sweet and savory indulgences.

Hit the Costa Cafe & Bakery for a quick snack or relaxing coffee break, and you won’t be disappointed.

Whit’s Frozen Custard of Port St. Lucie

Whit’s Frozen Custard in Port St. Lucie is known for its delicious frozen custard, a richer and creamier alternative to traditional ice cream, and is a perfect place for chilly treats around Port St. Lucie.

While Whit’s is a chain, they are known for being much higher quality than other similar locations, and the locals say it’s much cleaner and the staff is attentive and friendly.

Visitors can enjoy their custard in a cone, or in a bowl with countless different mix-ins, and the flavors are constantly rotated so there is always something new and delicious to look forward to.

Dixie Cream Donuts

port st lucie dessert restaurant

Dixie Cream Donuts is a must-visit for those with a sweet tooth for donuts.

This cozy little donut shop is beloved by locals for its various treats that seem to hit all the right nostalgia buttons, from your classic glazed coffee companions to more unique and inventive creations.

The free wifi and pleasant donut shop ambiance make it a great place to relax, get a sweet treat, and plan your next adventure.

Kilwin’s Chocolates and Ice Cream

Kilwin’s Chocolates and Ice Cream is a wonderful place to continue a whirlwind tour for dessert in the Port St. Lucie area.

This charming little shop in Tradition has much more than your typical ice cream shop and boasts options like hand-dipped caramel apples, caramel corn, chocolate-covered strawberries, fudge, and much more.

They also offer 32 flavors of super-premium ice cream that are all perfect for a cool treat on a hot Treasure Coast day.

Tropical Smoothie Cafe

More of an institutional pick, Tropical Smoothie Cafe serves a substantial variety of health-conscious smoothies and similar options, making it a great option for grabbing a dessert that isn’t packed with sugar.

The menu, while focused on smoothies, also lists wraps, sandwiches, flatbreads, and salads among their healthy-eating options.

Ice Cream Paleteria Calderon

ice cream dessert port st lucie

Ice Cream Paleteria Calderon is a delightful shop for authentic Mexican ice cream and treats.

It’s widely known for the range of unique flavors it creates as well as for the fresh ingredients used in its creations, and it provides delicious and colorful selections of ice creams and paletas.

This is a great family-friendly shop to take the kids to for an authentic taste of Mexican ice cream, or for anyone looking for a sweet escape.


CoolBeanz is an eclectic Port St. Lucie coffee shop and ice cream parlor that is known for having a lively atmosphere to match its delicious offerings.

It’s a very popular place due to the sheer variety of the gourmet coffee drinks, smoothies, and ice cream flavors it offers, and the shop’s friendly and welcoming vibe is a perfect match for the coastal area.

If you’re looking for a place where friends and family can gather to enjoy a refreshing ice cream treat.

Carvel Ice Cream & Cake Shoppe

If you’re in the mood to marvel at a massive range of ice cream treats, from soft serve to scoops, sundaes, shakes, and more, Carvel Ice Cream & Cake Shoppe is where you need to be.

They have BOGO Wednesday deals, offer custom cakes for any occasion, and stock plenty of take-home treats to keep your freezer full of frosty fun.

Wrapping Up

There you have it, tons of excellent places for dessert in Port St. Lucie as well as adjacent areas.

The Treasure Coast offers a unique journey through a wide variety of dessert specialties, with each shop having its own charm and signature atmosphere.

Whether you’re in the mood for the classic flavors of Kilwin’s, the boundless innovation and sugary delights found at Bomboloni Bakery-Café, or a quick but satisfying donut from Dixie Cream Donuts, the scene is as diverse as it is delectable, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

Picture of Josh



Post Info

  • Posted 5 months ago

Read More

The Insider's Guide to Florida's Treasure Coast


Receive the latest tips, information, & news!