The best pizza restaurants in Martin County offer a range of delicious pizzas, from Chicago-style to authentic Sicilian-style pies. Pizza is a favorite food for many, and it’s easy to find the perfect Martin County pizza spot. The Treasure Coast has tons of great Italian eateries, and many are included below in the list of the highest-rated pizza restaurants in Martin County, Florida.
Fantini’s ‘New Haven Style’ APizza Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar
Finding New Haven-style pizza isn’t easy, but it’s possible in Martin County at Fantini’s. New Haven–style pizza is a thin-crust, Neapolitan pizza that is coal-fired. The pizza is heavy on the char, and some may consider the style to taste “burnt,” but many people love the flavor. Fantini’s also serves the Foxon Park Soda, another Connecticut-based delicacy that’s difficult to find in Florida.
Many other Martin County restaurants can’t compete with the shop’s unique white clam pizza, cheese pizza with garlic, cannoli, bucatini, and garlic bread parmigiana. Diners who are craving a new haven-style pizza will enjoy Fantini’s. The restaurant is an excellent location for high-quality pizza in Martin County, as vouched for in Dave Portnoy’s Barstool Pizza Review.
Ian & Kye’s Pizza
Ian & Kye’s Pizza is one of the best pizzerias in Jensen Beach, Florida. The restaurant is renowned for its Chicago-style pizza. The decor and ambiance reflect an authentic Chicago style, with lots of seating inside and outside.
Ian & Kye’s has been in business for fifteen years and is well known among the locals. Diners recommend the Hancock, buffalo chicken pizza, Kye Willy, PA PA pepperoni pizza, garlic bites, cheesy garlic bread, and cheesecake for dessert. The restaurant offers a taste of Chicago in Downtown Jensen Beach.
Carmela’s Brick Oven Pizza
Carmela’s Brick Oven Pizza is one of the most popular pizza places in Martin County. The restaurant has a rustic and traditional atmosphere and offers an authentic and delicious Italian menu. The cheese pizza, margarita pizza, and garlic knots are all highly rated. The restaurant also offers excellent salad choices and an extensive selection of wine.
Carmela’s Brick Oven Pizza sometimes has live music, so it’s a great entertainment venue. The restaurant also has a bar area, so it’s ideal for diners who want to stop in for a quick bite to eat. Carmela’s is at 2311 SE Ocean Blvd in Stuart, Florida.
Luna Downtown Stuart
Luna Italian Cuisine sits in Historic Downtown Stuart in the Riverview shopping and dining district. Luna has been a local favorite since its opening in 1991 and is most known for its convenient takeout window with outdoor seating.
The restaurant inside offers a diverse menu, including specialty pizzas and a range of entrees to suit various tastes and budgets. Luna also provides discounts to patrons of the nearby Historic Lyric Theatre, making it a perfect spot for a pre-or post-show meal.
Luna is also involved in supporting some local non-profits and community initiatives across Martin County. For fast casual vibes, Luna truly sets the bar for Downtown Stuart restaurants worth visiting.
Luna is open Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, and Sunday with takeout and outside seating available from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM, and inside dining from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM.
Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza
Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza serves a delicious signature square-cut pub-style pizza usually only found in Chicago. The spot also serves delicious Chicago-style hot dogs and excellent cannolis. The restaurant also gets high ratings for its friendliness.
Diners receive exceptional service, and the waitstaff is nice and helpful. Visitors craving an authentic Chicago-style pizza cut in traditional squares will love Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza. Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza is also located in Downtown Stuart at 221 SE Ocean Blvd, Stuart, Florida.
Downtown Benny’s Pizza
Downtown Benny’s Pizza serves authentic New York-style pizza. The pizza shop uses a 70-year-old traditional family dough recipe, creating a thin and perfectly crispy dough that can please the pickiest palate.
Recommended dishes include the extra-large cheese pizza and Grandma’s pizza. Customers also love the garlic rolls. Downtown Benny’s also serves Philly cheesesteaks, gyros, and pasta. The pizza is impressive enough to persuade people who usually don’t eat pizza to give the place a try. The restaurant has two locations in Jensen Beach, a few in St. Lucie County, and just bought and rebranded Rusano’s Pizza in Palm City.
Anna’s Pizza
Anna’s Pizza is a casual, relaxed place serving classic pies and slices. The pizzas are made from scratch daily with fresh, premium ingredients. The restaurant is a favorite among locals and has a regular stream of visitors who enjoy the pizzas, calzones, Strombolis, garlic knots, and cinnamon knots.
Original Anna’s Pizza is a charming, family-owned restaurant that serves some of the best pizzas in Martin County. It’s a classic pizza shop offering generous, affordable pizza slices for $5. Original Anna’s in Jensen Beach is run by sweet, witty owners who enjoy engaging with customers. The staff is very welcoming, and customers are always greeted with a smile.
The restaurant is small and doesn’t have many seats, so diners may want to consider carryout. Customers recommend the Sicilian pizza. Other great dishes include baked ziti, lasagna, chicken parmesan, and garlic knots. Visitors looking for an authentic Italian-style pizza on the Treasure Coast will enjoy Original Anna’s Pizza. The restaurant has locations in Jensen Beach and Palm City.
Diners looking for a delicious pizza place with a chill atmosphere and generous portions should check out Anna’s Pizza.
Vesuvio’s Pizzeria
Vesuvio’s Pizzeria is a casual restaurant in Stuart that serves pizza, sandwiches, Italian bread, and pastries. Everything is house-made and cooked with fresh ingredients. The restaurant receives very high ratings from fans who love everything Vesuvio’s Pizzeria offers.
Diners who drop in around lunchtime can opt for the lunch special, which includes two slices and a soda for $7. Visitors should also try the Caesar salad or the eggplant rollatini. After having a slice, the restaurant has a variety of pastries and desserts that are all made in-house. Regulars recommend rainbow cookies for dessert.
Salerno Pizza
Salerno Pizza is a classic pizza place with fantastic food near Port Salerno. The restaurant opened in the 1980s and has been a go-to pizza spot for many locals in Stuart, Florida. Salerno’s fans appreciate the cozy atmosphere and service.
The pizza at Salerno’s is impressive, with just the right crispness and a delicious sauce topped with high-quality cheese. Diners should try the Grandma’s Pie, pepperoni, and cheese pizza. Regulars also recommend the pinwheel, garlic knots, wings, and meatballs.
Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza
Brooklyn Joe’s serves delicious pizza, pasta, and fresh salads in a relaxed atmosphere. The restaurant is family-owned and has a friendly staff that makes customers feel at home.
Recommended dishes include the White pizza, The Works pizza, the standard cheese pizza, garlic knots, Stromboli with ricotta, and sweet chili chicken wings. The restaurant also has a few vegetarian options.
Vegetarians can opt for the vegetable pizza, eggplant dinner or salad. Brooklyn Joe’s also has one of the best gluten-free pizzas in Martin County.
Brooklyn Joe’s is an excellent place for families as the pizzas are large and generous. Families and groups should order the 18-inch pizza, which provides plenty of food to satisfy a small crowd. Diners who want a local neighborhood pizzeria in a friendly atmosphere will enjoy Brooklyn Joe’s.
Anthony’s Coal-Fired Pizza & Wings
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Stuart, Florida, is an outstanding pizza place that can be busy but is well worth the wait. Locals appreciate the excellent service, which is highly rated as friendly and efficient. The franchise-chain restaurant is known for its delicious coal-fired crust, served from the oven to the table.
Recommended pizza dishes include Mike’s hot honey, cheese pizza, Carnivori, Margherita, and thick pepperoni. Regulars also love the restaurant’s fresh mozzarella, meatball ricotta, and Anthony’s classic Italian salad. The Italian restaurant also has delicious garlic parmesan wings.
Diners should try the pumpkin cheesecake for dessert. Anthony’s is also kid-friendly. Parents can request a little pizza dough for the kids to play with while they wait for the food to arrive. It’s a great place to take young kids of all ages.
Lynora’s
Lynora’s is a phenomenal Italian place in Jupiter, Florida. It’s technically just south of County Line Road, but gets a lot of traffic from Martin County residents in Tequesta and Hobe Sound. Jupiter is their newest location, so we figured it would be worth including in this list for anyone interested in trying it out.
Lynora’s has a beautiful atmosphere and excellent food and service. It was opened decades ago by immigrants from a tiny Italian island called Ponza. Lynora uses traditional Italian recipes to make its pizza and other dishes, and they’ve got additional locations in Palm Beach County.
Pizza recommendations at Lynora’s include the hot honey soppressata, white pepperoni, prosciutto rucola, and the Americano. The pizzas are high-quality, fresh, and flavorful. The housemade meatballs are also a hit. Lynora’s is a lovely spot for special occasions like a date or birthday celebration. The food is pricey but worth every penny.
More Great Martin County Pizza Restaurants
- Roma’s Pizza (Palm City)
- Big Apple Pizza (Multiple Treasure Coast Locations)
- Brock’s Surfside Grill & Pizzeria (Hutchinson Island)
- Pete’s Supreme Pizza (Stuart)
- Santos Pizza (Jensen Beach)
- Riko’s Thin Crust Pizza (Tequesta)
- The Brick Oven Pizza Company (Palm City)
- Uncle Guiseppe’s “Lil Bit A Brooklyn” (Stuart)
- Crafty Crust (Tequesta)
- Two Bros Pizza (Hobe Sound)
