The best Italian restaurants in Jensen Beach, Florida, offer a taste of Italy on the Treasure Coast. People love Italian food because the flavors are bold, and the cuisine is delicious and comforting. Jensen Beach is filled with many fantastic Italian restaurant options. Below are the best Italian restaurants in Jensen Beach, Florida.
Gigi’s Italian Restaurant Jensen Beach
Gigi’s is an intimate, family-owned southern Italian restaurant serving classic Italian dishes. The restaurant is named after the owners, Luigi and Assunta Lahara, who were both born in Naples, Italy. They opened their first Gigi’s Italian restaurant in Canada and eventually decided to bring their cooking to the Treasure Coast.
Gigi‘s is a great place to get authentic Neapolitan cuisine. They’ve become one of the highest-rated restaurants in Jensen Beach and the sit-down restaurant has a down-home feeling and friendly staff. Diners love the garlic knots, chicken, piccata cannoli, and tiramisu for dessert. Gigi’s Italian Restaurant is at 1322 NE Jensen Beach Blvd., Jensen Beach, Florida.
Ian & Kye’s Pizza
Ian & Kye’s Pizza is a great place to buy Italian food in Jensen Beach. The family-owned restaurant is known for its Chicago-style and other specialty gourmet pizzas. Diners in the mood for something different can try the Italian salad or the Chicago-famous Italian beef sandwich or order a side of meatballs.
Ian & Kye’s Pizza is one of the top pizza places in Martin County, with very high ratings from locals who love the pizza and the good vibes. The restaurant is small but has a charming atmosphere with plenty of indoor seating and a few outdoor tables for diners to enjoy the weather. Ian & Kye’s Pizza is in the heart of Downtown Jensen Beach at 3310 NE Indian River Dr., Jensen Beach, Florida.
Nonna’s
Nonna’s is one of the best Italian restaurants in Jensen Beach, Florida. The restaurant has outstanding food and service and is highly rated. Nonna’s is popular among tourists and locals and regularly runs weekly specials. Sunday at Nonna’s is a family day when kids ten and under can eat for free.
Mondays are the perfect time for martinis and meatballs. Tuesdays are pasta night, and diners can enjoy half-off wine and champagne bottles on Wednesdays. Nonna’s is at 10867 S. Ocean Dr., Jensen Beach, Florida.
Bomboloni Bakery Cafe
View this post on Instagram
Bomboloni is the perfect place for Italian baked goods in Jensen Beach, Florida. The cafe is a great place to meet friends for croissants and coffee. The owner is Italian and showcases his love for Italy in the restaurant’s atmosphere and food.
Bomboloni is well-loved by locals who enjoy the fresh coffee and authentic Italian food. The restaurant is known for its delicious bombolinis, Italian-filled donuts typically eaten as snacks or desserts. Other Italian favorites on the menu include Italian cannolis, cookies, and cronuts. If you’re looking for Jensen Beach coffee shops with an Italian flair, this is the perfect spot. Bomboloni Bakery Cafe is a place you visit to feel like you’re sitting in a café in Italy. Bomboloni Bakery Cafe is located at 3980 NW. Federal Highway, Jensen Beach, Florida.
Brock’s Surfside Grill & Pizza
Brock’s Surfside Grill & Pizza is a cozy restaurant that serves pizza, garlic knots, subs, and burgers. The restaurant opened in 1996. It has spent more than a decade serving the Jensen Beach community. Brock’s is very popular; people love the atmosphere and service.
Recommended dishes include white pizza, meat lovers pizza, sausage, mushroom pizza, stromboli, and garlic knots. Brock’s Surfside is an excellent family restaurant and a unique spot in Jensen Beach. It’s on Hutchinson Island at 10545 S. Ocean Dr., Jensen Beach, Florida.
Casa Italiano
Casa Italiano is another excellent pizza spot in Jensen Beach, Florida, also on Hutchinson Island. The restaurant serves New York-style pizza. The slices are enormous, and people appreciate the excellent prices. The restaurant also occasionally hosts an all-you-can-eat spaghetti and salad night for $14.99.
Casa Italiano has a casual and relaxed vibe. Its pizza menu is fantastic, and the restaurant has a good beer and wine list. Regulars love the calzones but also give high ratings to the supreme and cheese pizza. Casa Italiano is in the Island Shoppes at 4272 N. East Ocean Blvd., Jensen Beach, Florida.
Original Santos Wood-Fired Pizza Restaurant
Original Santos is a neighborhood pizzeria serving New York-style pizza. The owner was born in Palermo, Sicily, and started working in the family business, making pizza and cooking pasta at age ten. The owner is a self-taught, authentic Italian chef who uses his own unique recipes for his sauces, bread, and mozzarella. The pizza is delicious and cooked in a brick or regular oven. Wood-fired pizza is only available after 3 PM.
The restaurant has plenty of indoor and outdoor seating and offers a lively environment with live music in the evenings from 5 PM to 8 PM. Original Santos is excellent for live music, pizza, and lasagna. The restaurant is in the heart of Jensen Beach at 1319 N. East View Terrace, Jensen Beach, Florida.
Goodfellas Pizza, Pasta and Subs
View this post on Instagram
Goodfellas Pizza, Pasta, and Subs has an extensive menu of gourmet Italian dishes, baked pasta dishes, salads, subs, and stromboli. However, most people visit the restaurant for the pizza. Even the pickiest eater can find something they like at Goodfella’s Pizza.
The food at Goodfellas is highly rated by locals who love the Italian authenticity of the pizza and calzones. The employees are also very friendly and accommodating. Goodfellas is a great spot for authentic traditional Neapolitan pizza and a nice Italian restaurant. Jensen Beach’s Goodfellas Pizza, Pasta and Subs is at 1858 NE Jensen Beach Blvd., Jensen Beach, Florida. In total, they have 8 locations around the Treasure Coast that are all family-owned.
Downtown Benny’s Pizza
Downtown Benny’s Pizza is a neighborhood pizzeria that opened in Jensen Beach in 2019. The pizzeria serves New York-style pizza and other authentic Italian dishes. The restaurant uses a 70-year-old family dough recipe and fresh ingredients. Using original recipes, Downtown Benny’s sets itself apart from other Italian restaurants in Jensen Beach.
In addition to pizza, the restaurant serves spaghetti, eggplant parmesan, and meatball sandwiches. The garlic knots are a local favorite and an excellent spot for buffalo chicken pizza or calzone. Vegetarians can order a vegetable calzone filled with tomatoes, spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, and cheese pizza. Diners can create their own pizza, order a specialty pizza, or get a pizza by the slice. The restaurant also does catering and has locations in Stuart, Port St. Lucie, and most recently Palm City. Downtown Benny’s Pizza is at 2230 N. East Dixie Highway, Jensen Beach, Florida.
Port Barna
Port Barna is a newer Mediterranean restaurant in Jensen Beach that offers an excellent option for diners looking for Italian food. The restaurant is family-owned and serves cuisine from around the globe. Port Barna has a lovely atmosphere and provides a great dining experience with elegantly created dishes.
Diners who want Italian cuisine should try the fettuccine al burro, gnocchi marinara, creamy bacon carbonara pasta, pasta pescatore, or the chef’s pasta. The restaurant also makes a delicious bolognese pasta. Port Barna has very high ratings from locals who love the explosion of flavors and charming atmosphere. The restaurant is in the Treasure Coast Square Mall at 3478A NW Federal Highway, Jensen Beach, Florida.
