At a Glance: Best Pizza Near Hutchinson Island
- Closest to the beach: Brock’s Surfside Grill & Pizza and Nonna’s, both on S Ocean Dr
- Best thin and crispy crust: Ian & Kye’s Pizza
- Most authentic Italian: Gigi’s Italian Restaurant and Due Fratelli’s Pizzeria
- Best NY-style slice: Big Apple Pizza & Pasta
- Wood-fired option: Original Santos Wood Fired Pizza Restaurant
Pizza on Hutchinson Island and the Surrounding Jensen Beach Area
Finding great pizza near Hutchinson Island means knowing which spots locals actually return to week after week. The barrier island sits within Martin County, and the surrounding Jensen Beach and Port St. Lucie communities give visitors and residents a surprisingly deep bench of independently owned pizzerias to choose from. Whether you want a slice steps from the Atlantic or a full Italian dinner inland, the options below cover every style and budget.
Beachside Pizza: Walking Distance from the Water
Brock’s Surfside Grill & Pizza
Brock’s Surfside Grill & Pizza has been feeding beach crowds at 10545 S Ocean Dr in Jensen Beach since 1996, making it one of the most established pizza joints on South Hutchinson Island. The ocean-blue and yellow corner spot is a reliable stop for thin-crust pies, garlic knots, subs, and cold drinks at the bar. Lunch runs 11 AM to 3 PM and dinner from 3 to 9 PM, with happy hour from 3 to 6 PM daily.
The pizza here is consistently praised for its thin, crispy crust, and the beachside vibe keeps people coming back even after a long day on the sand. The outdoor bar area is newer and popular with regulars who like to linger. Staff are consistently described as attentive and quick to make things right when an order goes sideways.
📍 10545 S Ocean Dr, Jensen Beach, FL 34957
📞 (772) 229-9885
🍕 Must-Try: Thin-crust pizza, garlic knots
💬 Local Buzz: Reviewers specifically recommend the indoor and outdoor bar seating. One regular noted: “The pizza is awesome,” and the team is praised for going above and beyond on service recovery.
Nonna’s
Nonna’s, located at 10867 S Ocean Dr, is also right on Hutchinson Island and sits within the Kyle G’s family of Treasure Coast restaurants. The atmosphere leans casual and family-friendly, with a back patio featuring a fireplace that works well for cooler evenings. Gluten-free options are clearly marked on the menu, and Monday brings half-price appetizers.
The garlic olive oil served with bread draws particular praise from repeat visitors. Standout dishes include the lobster alla vodka, chicken francese, and house meatballs. Service is consistently described as attentive and warm.
View this post on Instagram
📍 10867 S Ocean Dr, Jensen Beach, FL 34957
📞 (772) 807-1404
🍕 Must-Try: Lobster alla vodka, garlic olive oil with bread
💬 Local Buzz: Customers mention the back patio as a great spot for dogs and families. Reviewers note the lobster alla vodka delivers large chunks of lobster for the price.
Pie Hole Wood Fired Pizza
Pie Hole Wood Pizza is a family-friendly pizza joint that serves delicious pizza, wings, and garlic knots covered with parmesan cheese. The restaurant sells specialty pizzas, but diners can build their own.
Reviewers suggest the Meat Lovers, loaded with sausage, meatballs, and pepperoni. The restaurant also makes great Italian subs.
📍 2510 S. Ocean Dr., Fort Pierce, Florida
📞 (772) 252-0241
Best Pizza Inland: Jensen Beach Neighborhood Spots
Gigi’s Italian Restaurant of Jensen Beach
Gigi’s Italian Restaurant of Jensen Beach has been operating since 1973, making it one of the oldest continuously running Italian restaurants in Martin County. Located at 1322 NE Jensen Beach Blvd, this intimate Southern Italian eatery is family-owned and operated, with father-and-son team Joe and Sebastian regularly on the floor. The atmosphere feels more like a dinner at a friend’s house than a restaurant.
The pizza here is made with high-quality ingredients and earns consistent five-star reviews. Penne alla vodka, tiramisu, and the house salad are recurring favorites. Date-night visitors and family groups both describe leaving with leftovers and plans to return.
📍 1322 NE Jensen Beach Blvd, Jensen Beach, FL 34957
📞 (772) 225-6444
🍕 Must-Try: Pizza, penne alla vodka, tiramisu
💬 Local Buzz: Reviewers call it “the best Italian restaurant in the area.” Regulars note the food tastes even better reheated the next day.
Ian & Kye’s Pizza
Ian & Kye’s Pizza at 3310 NE Indian River Dr is a Chicago-influenced thin-crust pizzeria that has built a loyal following among Treasure Coast pizza enthusiasts. The signature square-cut style and bold seasoning set it apart from the NY-style competition. Fans drive from Hobe Sound and beyond specifically for the crust, which regulars describe as perfectly crisp and sturdy.
The Chi Town sausage pie and the Parmesan garlic wings are the most frequently praised items in reviews. The specialty pies are worth exploring, but the build-your-own option lets you dial in exactly what you want. This spot earns a 4.7 rating across nearly 620 reviews.
View this post on Instagram
📍 3310 NE Indian River Dr, Jensen Beach, FL 34957
📞 (772) 334-5074
🍕 Must-Try: Chi Town sausage pie, Parmesan garlic wings
💬 Local Buzz: Reviewers suggest reheating at 425 degrees for 4 minutes if taking pizza home. One customer calls it “our new favorite pizza place” and plans to go weekly.
Due Fratelli’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Due Fratelli’s Pizzeria and Restaurant at 4272 NE Ocean Blvd recently reopened under new ownership, and early reviews under the new direction are overwhelmingly positive. Owner Ms. Toni, described as warm and welcoming by multiple reviewers, leads a team that emphasizes fresh ingredients and homemade sauces. Gluten-free pizza is available, which is still relatively uncommon among independent pizzerias in the Jensen Beach area.
The Sicilian pizza, broccoli cavatelli, and chicken marsala are standouts. Catering is available and has been used for private retirement luncheons and group events. This spot holds a 4.7 rating, the highest among the verified pizzerias in the area.
📍 4272 NE Ocean Blvd, Jensen Beach, FL 34957
📞 (772) 444-3729
🍕 Must-Try: Sicilian pizza, chicken marsala, tiramisu
💬 Local Buzz: Customers mention the peanut butter pie as an unexpected dessert highlight. Multiple reviewers note the homemade tomato sauce as a standout detail.
Original Santos Wood Fired Pizza Restaurant
Original Santos Wood Fired Pizza Restaurant at 1319 NE Sunview Terrace in Jensen Beach is the area’s primary option for wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizza. The cozy interior and back patio attract a mix of locals and visitors, and the restaurant regularly features live music. The wood-fired oven produces a charred, blistered crust that sets it apart from every other pizzeria on this list.
Beyond pizza, the meatballs, eggplant parm, and chicken francese earn strong reviews. The restaurant is a busy spot, and reviewers have noted that wait times can run long on peak evenings. Owner Tony is frequently seen checking on tables.
📍 1319 NE Sunview Terrace, Jensen Beach, FL 34957
📞 (772) 261-8427
🍕 Must-Try: Wood-fired pizza, meatballs, eggplant parm
💬 Local Buzz: Regulars say it’s “by far the best Italian food in Jensen Beach.” First-time visitors should call ahead or expect a wait on Friday and Saturday evenings.
Big Apple Pizza & Pasta
Big Apple Pizza & Pasta at 3359 NW Main Ave in Jensen Beach is a family-owned New York-style pizzeria with a no-frills setup that delivers on quality. Grab your drink from the cooler at the door, watch the dough get tossed through the open kitchen, and order the garlic knots without hesitation. Monday and Tuesday specials on large cheese pizzas make this one of the best value options in the area.
📍 3359 NW Main Ave, Jensen Beach, FL 34957 (Another option in Fort Pierce)
📞 (772) 208-5496
🍕 Must-Try: Garlic knots, veggie pizza, cheeseburger pizza
💬 Local Buzz: The Monday and Tuesday large cheese pizza deal is a recurring tip from reviewers. Staff are praised for splitting toppings without upcharging.
Options Worth the Drive
Goodfella’s
Goodfella’s has multiple locations in the area, one is on Hutchinson Island and the other is inland. The restaurants off New York-style pizza, pasta, subs, and more. They also deliver to the surrounding area.
Many reviewers mention that the service staff is always fast and friendly. Most recommend White Pie, Steak Supreme Pizza, or Chicken Parmesean. If you’re looking for Gluten Free crust, this is a great place to consider.
📍 825 Seaway Dr, Fort Pierce, FL 34949, 2993 S 25th St, Fort Pierce, FL 34981
📞 (772) 460-6022
Bella Roma Bakery & Pizzeria
Bella Roma Bakery & Pizzeria at 475 Riomar Dr in Port St. Lucie doubles as an Italian pastry shop, making it unique among all the pizzerias on the Treasure Coast. Visitors from the Northeast with high pizza standards consistently note that it holds up. The baked ziti and garlic knots anchor the savory menu, while the tiramisu and lobster tail pastry anchor dessert.
- 📍 475 Riomar Dr, Port St. Lucie, FL 34952
- 📞 (772) 343-7405
- 🍕 Must-Try: Garlic knots, baked ziti, tiramisu, lobster tail pastry
- 💬 Local Buzz: Reviewers from the NYC and NJ area call it “a gem” for the region. Dog-friendly outdoor seating is noted as a bonus by multiple regulars.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza near Hutchinson Island, FL?
Brock’s Surfside Grill & Pizza and Nonna’s are the closest pizza options directly on Hutchinson Island along S Ocean Dr. For the highest-rated experience nearby, Due Fratelli’s Pizzeria and Ian & Kye’s Pizza both hold a 4.7-star rating across hundreds of reviews in Jensen Beach.
Is there gluten-free pizza near Hutchinson Island?
Yes. Due Fratelli’s Pizzeria and Restaurant on NE Ocean Blvd in Jensen Beach offers gluten-free pizza crust. Nonna’s on S Ocean Dr also clearly marks gluten-free menu options, though the selection is limited.
Where can I find Chicago-style pizza on the Treasure Coast?
Ian & Kye’s Pizza on NE Indian River Dr in Jensen Beach is the area’s primary option for Chicago-influenced thin-crust, square-cut pizza. The Chi Town sausage pie is the most recommended specialty pie on the menu.
Which Jensen Beach pizza restaurant has been open the longest?
Gigi’s Italian Restaurant of Jensen Beach on NE Jensen Beach Blvd has been open since 1973, making it the longest-running Italian restaurant in the immediate area, according to the business’s own history. It remains family owned and operated today.
Which pizzerias near Hutchinson Island offer catering?
Due Fratelli’s Pizzeria and Restaurant actively offers catering services and has handled private retirement luncheons and group events with Italian buffet menus. Bella Roma Bakery & Pizzeria in Port St. Lucie also offers a full menu suitable for catered events.
