At a Glance: Best Pizza in Hobe Sound
- Two Brothers Pizza: Best for quick delivery and classic NY-style pies
- Big Apple Pizza & Pasta: 47-year legacy, authentic Sicilian crust, budget-friendly slices
- Amato’s Ristorante & Pizzeria: Sit-down Italian experience with New Haven-style pizza and a full menu
- The Grove: Upscale Italian dining with pizza as part of a broader, chef-driven menu
The Pizza Scene in Hobe Sound, Florida
Finding great pizza in Hobe Sound is easier than most people expect. This small Martin County community along the Treasure Coast punches well above its weight, with four distinct spots offering everything from a fast weeknight delivery to a candlelit Italian dinner. Each restaurant has carved out its own identity, and the local customer base is loyal and vocal about what makes each one worth visiting.
Hobe Sound sits between Jupiter to the south and Stuart to the north along US-1 and SE Federal Highway, so these restaurants serve both full-time residents and visitors passing through Martin County. The options below are ranked by a combination of ratings, review volume, and verified local sentiment.
Top Pizza Spots in Hobe Sound
Two Brothers Pizza
Two Brothers Pizza is the go-to for casual, no-fuss pizza in Hobe Sound. With a 4.5-star rating across 513 reviews, it earns the top spot for consistent quality and speed. Reviewers consistently praise the thin-to-medium crust, balanced sauce, and generous cheese pull. The calzone gets repeated mentions as a sleeper hit, described by one verified reviewer as having “very light and fresh dough and the perfect amount of cheese and ricotta.”
Walk-in customers report getting a fresh hot pie in as little as five to seven minutes. Delivery is available, though a few reviewers note the driver communication could be clearer. The Monday specials are a recurring tip shared among locals, making it a popular pick for early-week pizza nights.
📍 8423 SE Church St, Hobe Sound, FL 33455
📞 (772) 402-5056
🍕 Must-Try: Meat lovers pizza, cheese calzone
💬 Local Buzz: Regulars recommend the Monday deals and note the garlic knots lean more pesto-and-oil than traditional butter, so manage expectations accordingly
Big Apple Pizza & Pasta
Big Apple Pizza & Pasta has been feeding Hobe Sound for over 47 years, making it the most established pizza institution in town. Its 4.1-star rating across 306 reviews reflects a loyal base that keeps coming back for the Sicilian crust and New York-style slices. One reviewer called the spinach white slice “the best recommendation I’ve had in years,” which tracks with how often that item appears in positive feedback.
The price point is notably accessible. Reviewers describe it as one of the most affordable ways to eat well in Martin County. The all-you-can-eat deal on select weekday evenings, reportedly priced around $11.99, is a community staple that draws regulars in reliably. Staff members like Gia and Kristine are called out by name in multiple reviews, which speaks to the family-run feel of the operation.
📍 11722 SE Federal Hwy, Hobe Sound, FL 33455
📞 (772) 546-2073
🌐 bigapplepizza.com
🍕 Must-Try: Spinach white slice, Mama Lino’s pizza, mozzarella sticks
💬 Local Buzz: Check for the all-you-can-eat evenings if you want serious value; the free garlic knots served with meals are a recurring fan favorite
Amato’s Ristorante & Pizzeria
View this post on Instagram
Amato’s Ristorante & Pizzeria is the neighborhood Italian restaurant that doubles as a serious pizza destination. Rated 4.4 stars across 327 reviews, it occupies a unique position in Hobe Sound by offering New Haven-style pizza alongside a full sit-down Italian menu. The restaurant has been a community fixture since its opening, and a member of the owning family is reportedly on-site regularly, which reviewers consistently notice and appreciate.
Recent reviews highlight upgrades to the kitchen under new leadership. A revised marinara sauce with a less acidic finish has drawn praise from food-savvy diners. The atmosphere is warm and personal, with longtime staff member Amanda recognized in multiple reviews for knowing guests by name. This is the spot for a proper Italian dinner, not just a quick slice.
📍 9042 SE Bridge Rd, Hobe Sound, FL 33455
📞 (772) 546-2220
🌐 amatoshobesoundfl.com
🍕 Must-Try: New Haven-style pizza, clam appetizer, cannoli
💬 Local Buzz: Reservations are strongly recommended on weekends; regulars note the food quality has noticeably improved in recent seasons
The Grove
The Grove earns its 4.7-star rating across 716 reviews by delivering a full Italian dining experience that happens to include excellent pizza. It is the highest-rated restaurant on this list by volume and score, and the reviews back it up with consistent praise for both food and service. Chef Nick is mentioned by name for elevated specials like osso buco and barramundi, reflecting a kitchen that takes its craft seriously.
View this post on Instagram
Pizza here exists within a broader Italian menu that includes chicken piccata, risotto, and tiramisu. If you want pizza as the centerpiece of a complete dinner with wine, The Grove delivers. The team is described as attentive, the wine list is curated, and the ambiance supports conversation without being overly formal.
📍 8815 SE Bridge Rd, Hobe Sound, FL 33455
📞 (772) 402-5410
🌐 thegrovehobesound.com
🍕 Must-Try: Chef specials, tiramisu, anything paired with their wine selection
💬 Local Buzz: Book online through their website, especially for Valentine’s Day or weekend dinners; server Kim is specifically praised for attentive group service
What to Know Before You Order Pizza in Hobe Sound
Hobe Sound is a small community within Martin County, and dining options are more concentrated than in neighboring Stuart or Port St. Lucie. That means the pizza restaurants here carry a heavier load of local loyalty, and the quality at each spot reflects years of refinement in response to a tight-knit customer base.
Martin County’s growth in recent years, driven in part by an influx of residents from South Florida and the broader Treasure Coast region, has raised expectations for local dining. These four restaurants have all adapted, whether through kitchen upgrades at Amato’s, expanded delivery at Two Brothers, or the elevated dining experience at The Grove.
Hours matter in Hobe Sound. At least one review notes an early closure at Two Brothers Pizza on a weekend evening, so calling ahead is smart if you are ordering after 7:30 PM. Most restaurants here operate on slightly shorter windows than their urban counterparts.
Frequently Asked Questions: Pizza in Hobe Sound
What is the best pizza place in Hobe Sound, FL?
Based on ratings and review volume, Two Brothers Pizza leads for casual pizza with a 4.5-star rating. For a full Italian dining experience with pizza, The Grove holds the highest overall rating at 4.7 stars across 716 reviews.
Does Hobe Sound have New York-style pizza?
Yes. Big Apple Pizza & Pasta specializes in authentic New York-style and Sicilian-style pizza and has operated in Hobe Sound for over 47 years. Two Brothers Pizza also serves a thin-to-medium crust that reviewers frequently compare to NY-style.
Is there New Haven-style pizza in Hobe Sound?
Amato’s Ristorante & Pizzeria on SE Bridge Rd is the local source for New Haven-style pizza, paired with a full Italian menu and a family-run atmosphere.
Which Hobe Sound pizza restaurant is best for a sit-down dinner?
Both The Grove and Amato’s Ristorante & Pizzeria offer full table service with broader Italian menus. The Grove is the more upscale of the two, with a curated wine bar, chef-driven specials, and online reservations.
What is the most affordable pizza option in Hobe Sound?
Big Apple Pizza & Pasta is consistently described by reviewers as the most budget-friendly option, with individual slices, the spinach white pizza, and periodic all-you-can-eat dinner deals making it the top pick for value in Martin County.
