At a Glance: Best Pizza in Fort Pierce
- Best wood-fired: Pie Hole Wood Fired Pizza or Santos Wood Fired Pizza
- Best NY-style slice: Lorenzo’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria or Downtown Benny’s Pizza
- Best family Italian: Nino’s Lakewood Park or Big Apple Pizza
- Best upscale Italian with pizza: Casa Pasta
- Best brewery pizza: Sailfish Brewing Company
Wood-Fired Pizza in Fort Pierce
Fort Pierce has two serious contenders for wood-fired pizza, and both earn their reputation with real craft and consistent quality.
Pie Hole Wood Fired Pizza
Pie Hole Wood Fired Pizza sits along South Ocean Drive on Hutchinson Island near the inlet, making it one of the most atmospherically placed pizzerias on the Treasure Coast. The wood-fired oven delivers a signature smoky aroma and blistered, crispy crust that loyal customers describe as “world-class.” Beyond pizza, the kitchen turns out solid Italian plates, including fettuccine Alfredo and rigatoni al a vodka that reviewers call “top notch.”
📍 2510 S Ocean Dr, Fort Pierce, FL 34949
⭐ 4.5/5 (1,647 reviews)
🍕 Must-Try: Wood-fired pizza, garlic knots, mozzarella sticks
📞 (772) 252-0241
Local Buzz: Regulars love the crispy cupped pepperoni and the knowledgeable, friendly service. A small number of reviews flag inconsistency in sauce and char levels, so arrive with an open mind toward the wood-fired style.
Santos Wood Fired Pizza
Santos Wood Fired Pizza on West Midway Road is a local institution with a fiercely loyal following. Reviewers from New York and Long Island, places not known for tolerating bad pizza, consistently call it the best Italian food on the Treasure Coast. The Grandma Sicilian is a standout. The garlic knots, loaded with chunked fresh garlic, oregano, and olive oil, are described in multiple reviews as the best ever made.
📍 2455 W Midway Rd, Fort Pierce, FL 34981
⭐ 4.5/5 (59 reviews)
🍕 Must-Try: Grandma Sicilian, garlic knots, quattro fromage
📞 (772) 241-9181
Local Buzz: Santos earns repeat visits for consistency and affordability. The review count is still growing at the newer Midway Road location, but the quality reputation stretches back over a decade.
Classic NY-Style and Old-School Pizzerias
Lorenzo’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
Lorenzo’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria at 222 Orange Ave in Downtown Fort Pierce is the closest thing to a Brooklyn neighborhood restaurant you will find in St. Lucie County. Hand-made everything, hot portions, and a family-operated kitchen define the experience. The angel hair onion rings and fresh garlic knots are local legends, and the pizza is described by longtime customers as “perfectly cooked by someone who does not cut corners.”
📍 222 Orange Ave, Fort Pierce, FL 34950
⭐ 4.5/5 (860 reviews)
🍕 Must-Try: Extra-large pizza, garlic knots, lasagna
📞 (772) 460-5445
Local Buzz: Families who moved away still make Lorenzo’s their first stop when returning to Fort Pierce. The remodeled interior and refreshed menu have earned new fans while keeping the old-school soul intact.
Downtown Benny’s Pizza
View this post on Instagram
Downtown Benny’s Pizza on Oleander Avenue is a quiet favorite with Queens, New York roots behind the current ownership. The meat calzone is enormous, even in the small size, and the marinara sauce hits a near-perfect balance of sweet and tangy. The slice deal and gluten-free crust options make it accessible to a wide range of diners.
📍 4919 Oleander Ave, Fort Pierce, FL 34982
⭐ 4.5/5 (243 reviews)
🍕 Must-Try: Meat calzone, pepperoni slice, garlic knots
📞 (772) 828-3057
Local Buzz: Regulars say the new owners have made the pizza even better than before. The staff is cited repeatedly for warmth and genuine hospitality.
Neighborhood Staples Worth Knowing
Nino’s Lakewood Park
View this post on Instagram
Nino’s Lakewood Park on Turnpike Feeder Road is a reliable, family-friendly destination with a large menu that includes NY-style pizzas, calzones, subs, and full Italian entrees. The owners and staff are credited with creating a “Cheers”-like atmosphere where regulars feel at home. The chicken Marafredo is a crowd favorite beyond the pizza menu.
📍 5018 Turnpike Feeder Rd, Fort Pierce, FL 34951
⭐ 4.3/5 (989 reviews)
🍕 Must-Try: Large pizza, calzone with steak, garlic knots
📞 (772) 466-7644
Big Apple Pizza
Big Apple Pizza on South 35th Street is a family-owned local chain with a loyal five-plus-year customer base. The eggplant parmigiana and chicken wings draw as many compliments as the pizza itself. Beer on tap and made-to-order food with no sneaky portion reductions keep regulars coming back.
📍 2311 S 35th St, Fort Pierce, FL 34981
⭐ 4.3/5 (674 reviews)
🍕 Must-Try: White pizza, eggplant parm, chicken wings
📞 (772) 466-8303
📰 Read More: Best Lunch Options in Fort Pierce
Loutina’s Pizza
View this post on Instagram
Loutina’s Pizza on North Kings Highway serves the Lakewood Park corridor with thin-crust pizzas, wings, subs, and a friendly neighborhood feel. Fans in the area often rank it above nearby competitors for consistency and generosity of portions.
📍 4880 N Kings Hwy, Fort Pierce, FL 34951
⭐ 4.2/5 (599 reviews)
🍕 Must-Try: Thin-crust pizza, buffalo chicken sandwich, stromboli
📞 (772) 595-9773
Goodfella’s Pizza, Pasta & Subs
Goodfella’s Pizza operates two Fort Pierce locations, one on South 25th Street and another on Seaway Drive near the waterfront. Both serve NY-style pizza, subs, and pastas with delivery available. The garlic knots and cannoli earn the strongest individual praise. The Seaway Drive location benefits from a beautiful setting close to the Fort Pierce waterfront district.
📍 2993 S 25th St, Fort Pierce, FL 34981 | 825 Seaway Dr, Fort Pierce, FL 34949
⭐ 4.0 to 4.1/5 (900+ reviews combined)
🍕 Must-Try: Garlic knots, Grandma’s pizza, thin-crust meat lovers
When Pizza is Part of a Bigger Night Out
Sailfish Brewing Company
Sailfish Brewing Company on North 2nd Street in downtown Fort Pierce is a craft brewery with pizza on the menu and a lively, family-friendly atmosphere. Arcade games, rotating taps, and a large open layout make it one of the most social spots in the city. The pizza is genuinely good, not an afterthought, though the real draw is the full experience. The Fort Pierce Community Redevelopment Agency has recognized the North 2nd Street corridor as a key anchor for downtown revitalization, and Sailfish Brewing sits at its center.
📍 130 N 2nd St, Fort Pierce, FL 34950
⭐ 4.6/5 (838 reviews)
🍺 Pairs With: Craft beer flights, pizza by the pie
📞 (772) 577-4382
Casa Pasta
Casa Pasta at 100 South 2nd Street is not primarily a pizzeria, but the homemade pasta, European-style brunch, and authentic Italian kitchen earn it a place in any serious Fort Pierce food conversation. Reviewers call it a “10 out of 10” for date nights and special occasions.
📍 100 S 2nd St, Fort Pierce, FL 34950
⭐ 4.9/5 (2,197 reviews)
🍝 Best For: Upscale Italian dining, special occasions, date night
📞 (772) 882-4984
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza in Fort Pierce, FL?
Based on ratings and review volume, Lorenzo’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, Pie Hole Wood Fired Pizza, and Santos Wood Fired Pizza consistently rank at the top. Lorenzo’s leads for NY-style, while Pie Hole and Santos are the go-to choices for wood-fired crust.
Where can I get wood-fired pizza in Fort Pierce?
Pie Hole Wood Fired Pizza on South Ocean Drive and Santos Wood Fired Pizza on West Midway Road are the two dedicated wood-fired options in Fort Pierce. Both hold a 4.5-star rating.
Where can I get pizza by the slice in Fort Pierce?
Downtown Benny’s Pizza on Oleander Avenue and Goodfella’s Pizza on South 25th Street both offer pizza by the slice. The BreakRoom in Port St. Lucie just south of the county line runs a popular two-slice-and-soda walk-in special for around $6.50.
Is there good NY-style pizza in Fort Pierce?
Yes. Lorenzo’s, Santos, Big Apple Pizza, Downtown Benny’s, and Nino’s Lakewood Park all have strong New York-style credentials, with multiple reviews from self-described native New Yorkers vouching for authenticity.
What Fort Pierce pizza places offer delivery?
Goodfella’s Pizza (both locations), AJ’s Pizza, Subs, and Wings on Oleander Avenue, and Loutina’s Pizza on North Kings Highway all offer delivery. Goodfella’s in particular is frequently cited for fast, friendly delivery service.
