At a Glance: Stuart’s Top Pizza Spots
- The Pizza Gene and Vesuvio’s Pizzeria lead the pack with 4.7 ratings and strong local followings
- Salerno Pizza earns 4.7 stars across 836 reviews, with standout delivery and catering
- Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza is the go-to for authentic Chicago-style thin crust
- Piatto Divino offers the most upscale, imported-ingredient Neapolitan experience
- Ian & Kye’s Pizza is the newest standout with a perfect 5.0 rating
Artisan and Craft Pizza: Stuart’s Highest-Rated Spots
The Pizza Gene
The Pizza Gene on SE Monterey Road consistently draws the strongest praise of any pizza in Stuart, with reviewers citing owner Pat’s hands-on approach and the quality of every ingredient as the defining difference.
📍 424 SE Monterey Rd, Stuart, FL 34994
📞 (772) 888-3338
🌐 pizzagene.com
🍕 Must-Try: The Abomination pizza, any daily slice
Local Buzz: Regulars emphasize that the dough is light, airy, chewy, and blistered correctly, and that Pat personally checks on tables and remembers faces. One reviewer called it “the best pizza in the area by a mile.” A small outdoor space is available for dine-in.
Vesuvio’s Pizzeria
Vesuvio’s Pizzeria on SE Federal Highway is a neighborhood anchor with 655 reviews and a 4.7 rating. It is known for its scratch-made Italian breads, pastries, and a counter loaded with rainbow cookies and other Italian sweets.
View this post on Instagram
📍 4225 SE Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34997
📞 (772) 288-3373
🌐 facebook.com/VesuviosPizzeriaStuart
🍕 Must-Try: Veggie or meat amore pizza, garlic knots, Italian pastries
Local Buzz: Reviewers from Brooklyn families call this their benchmark for New York-style pizza in Stuart. One regular notes they visit “almost every weekend.” The housemade sweets counter surprises first-time visitors.
Piatto Divino
Piatto Divino on SE Ocean Boulevard is the most ingredient-focused restaurant on this list, importing its pizza oven from Naples and using high-quality imported products throughout the menu.
📍 2891 SE Ocean Blvd, Stuart, FL 34996
📞 (772) 872-6971
🌐 piattodivino.com
🍕 Must-Try: Margherita pizza, lobster ravioli, warm chocolate soufflé
Local Buzz: Multiple reviewers describe the wood-fired crust as “light, airy, and charred just right.” The gluten-free pizza option is noted as genuinely impressive. Reviewers also highlight the stylish ambiance and outdoor, pet-friendly seating.
Chicago-Style and Regional Specialty Pizza in Stuart
Ian & Kye’s Pizza
Ian & Kye’s Pizza on SE M.L.K. Jr Blvd in Downtown Stuart is the newest entry on this list and carries a perfect 5.0 rating across 72 reviews. The brick-oven, cracker-thin crust is its calling card.
View this post on Instagram
📍 117 SE M.L.K. Jr Blvd, Stuart, FL 34994
📞 (772) 254-5053
🌐 iankyespizza.com
🍕 Must-Try: Chi Town pizza, zeppoli, garlic bread
Local Buzz: Reviewers from Chicago call it “better than the other Chicago-style pizza in town.” The outdoor patio seating and family-business atmosphere earn repeated mention. One reviewer said they used to drive an hour to Delray Beach for comparable pizza before Ian & Kye’s opened.
Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza
Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza on SE Ocean Boulevard in Downtown Stuart is the Treasure Coast’s most recognized destination for Chicago-style thin crust, Italian beef, and Chicago-style hot dogs.
📍 221 SE Ocean Blvd, Stuart, FL 34994
📞 (772) 288-9810
🌐 pusaterispizza.com
🍕 Must-Try: Cheese garlic bread, pepperoni pizza with hot honey, peanut butter pie
Local Buzz: Visitors from the Chicago area specifically drive 30 to 40 minutes for the Italian beef with giardiniera. Staff hospitality is mentioned repeatedly. One long-term reviewer noted price and cheese quantity changes over the past 18 months, worth knowing before you go.
New Haven & East Coast Style Pizza
Fantini’s Italian Restaurant
Fantini’s Italian Restaurant on NW Federal Highway is Stuart’s dedicated New Haven-style apizza destination, with a coal-fired oven producing charred, thin-crust pies that attract regulars from across Martin County and St. Lucie County.
View this post on Instagram
📍 1670 NW Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34994
📞 (772) 692-9980
🌐 fantinisapizza.com
🍕 Must-Try: Tomato pie, white clam pizza, tiramisu
Local Buzz: One reviewer who has visited multiple times per month for two years calls it the best pizza between Stuart and Port St. Lucie. The bar atmosphere and full dinner menu make it a complete evening destination. A few reviewers note the music volume runs high.
Family Pizzerias With Deep Local Roots
Salerno Pizza
Salerno Pizza on SE Federal Highway in south Stuart earns a 4.7 rating across 836 reviews, making it one of the most consistently reviewed independent pizzerias in Martin County.
📍 5557 SE Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34997
📞 (772) 286-5505
🌐 mysalernopizza.com
🍕 Must-Try: Chocolate-dipped cannolis, garlic knots, chicken cutlet parm sandwich
Local Buzz: Families describe eating here one to three times per week. Staff remember customer names, which reviewers cite as a meaningful detail. Gluten-free pizza earns specific praise for its thin, crispy crust. Office catering orders, including lasagna and chicken francese, have high repeat rates.
Carmela’s Brick Oven Pizza
Carmela’s Brick Oven Pizza on SE Ocean Boulevard blends rustic pizzeria with a wine bar atmosphere and live music, making it one of the more versatile dining options in Stuart.
📍 2311 SE Ocean Blvd, Stuart, FL 34996
📞 (772) 286-0877
🌐 carmelaspizza.com
🍕 Must-Try: Grandma’s pizza with sausage and meatballs, antipasto salad, linguine in clam sauce
Local Buzz: Long-term customers note the same owner and staff have maintained consistent quality across years. A $9 lunch special including two slices, a drink, and a garlic knot is a standout value that reviewers specifically recommend.
View this post on Instagram
Original Anna’s Pizza
Original Anna’s Pizza on NE Dixie Hwy in Stuart is cash-only, loud, and purely focused on the pizza itself. The 24-inch “Whopper” is a regional landmark.
📍 150 NE Dixie Hwy, Stuart, FL 34994
📞 (772) 692-4600
💵 Cash Only
🍕 Must-Try: Sicilian slice, garlic knots, any size by the slice starting at $5
Local Buzz: Reviewers consistently describe the crust as among the best in Florida. Watching Anna stir the sauce from the dining area is part of the experience. Note that cash only is strictly enforced, waits can exceed expectations, and prices have drawn comment.
Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza
Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza on SE Dixie Highway is a family-run thin-crust pizzeria with 640 reviews and a 4.6 rating. The zeppolis and homemade mozzarella sticks are cult favorites.
📍 3466 SE Dixie Hwy, Stuart, FL 34997
📞 (772) 219-2211
🌐 brooklynjoespizza.com
🍕 Must-Try: Thin crust pepperoni pie, zeppolis, homemade mozzarella sticks
Local Buzz: Visitors from Philadelphia and New Jersey hold this to a high regional standard and say it delivers. Owner Nate is mentioned by name in multiple reviews as the reason the place works.
FAQ About Pizza in Stuart, FL
What is the highest-rated pizza place in Stuart, FL?
Ian & Kye’s Pizza holds a perfect 5.0 rating, though its review count is still growing. Among high-volume options, The Pizza Gene, Vesuvio’s Pizzeria, and Salerno Pizza all hold 4.7 ratings across hundreds of reviews, making them the most statistically reliable top choices.
Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Stuart?
Several pizzerias in Stuart offer gluten-free options. Salerno Pizza, Piatto Divino, and Carmela’s Brick Oven Pizza each receive positive specific mentions for their gluten-free crusts in verified customer reviews.
Where is the best Chicago-style pizza in Stuart?
Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza is the most established and reviewed Chicago-style option, with 1,244 reviews and a 4.5 rating. Ian & Kye’s Pizza is a newer contender that some reviewers with Chicago roots say surpasses it on thin-crust execution.
Is there New Haven-style pizza in Stuart?
Yes. Fantini’s Italian Restaurant on NW Federal Highway specializes in New Haven-style apizza with a coal-fired, charred thin crust. It is the only dedicated New Haven-style pizzeria among verified Stuart locations.
Which Stuart pizza places are best for large groups or catering?
Salerno Pizza and Carmela’s Brick Oven Pizza receive the most specific catering praise in local reviews. La Forchetta on SW Lost River Road and Casa Giuseppe’s Italian Grill on SE Indian Street also offer catering and are noted for large-format Italian meals across Martin County.
